MUSIC REVIEW: Streisand's 'Walls' Strikes Strident Anti-Trump Tone
This cover image released by Columbia Records shows "Walls" a release by Barbra Streisand. (Columbia Records via AP)
Barbra Streisand, āWallsā (Columbia Records)
Itās no surprise that fervent Hillary Clinton supporter and longtime Democratic Party fundraiser Barbra Streisand doesnāt think much of Donald Trump. The surprise is that the legendary singer chose to devote much of her new album, āWalls,ā to a series of laments about the U.S. presidentās policies.
Streisand never mentions the president by name, but she doesnāt have to. Opening track āWhatās on My Mindā speaks of her dashed hopes in the current era and asks, āHow did we come to this divide?ā The next one, āDonāt Lie to Me,ā is even more direct, beginning with, āWhy canāt you just tell me the truth? Hard to believe the things you say.ā
The title track complains about the divisive nature of building walls ā a familiar Trump campaign promise ā and even picks up Clintonās campaign theme that it is better to build bridges instead.
As a counterpoint to this gloom, she combines John Lennonās wistful āImagineā with the Louis Armstrong classic āWhat a Wonderful Worldā and also covers āWhat the World Needs Nowā in a paean to the redemptive power of love.
But those more hopeful tunes donāt really save this offering from its lugubrious tone. Streisandās vocal range and control are still extraordinary, but the lyrics often fall flat, as in āLady Liberty,ā which calls for the Statue of Liberty to āshow us how to stand and feel a little prouder.ā
Her magnificent voice, at times quivering with deeply felt emotion, may not be the perfect instrument for expressing pointed political anger, and the soft string accompaniment becomes a bit predictable.
The Trump era will surely produce a strong, outspoken musical response, perhaps from newer artists who have yet to be heard on the national stage, but Streisand here fails to break new ground. āWallsā will likely please her legions of fans ā she is one of the most popular recording artists of the last six decades ā but may not bring many new listeners to her side.
BY GREGORY KATZ, AP
Barbra Streisand, āWallsā (Columbia Records)
Itās no surprise that fervent Hillary Clinton supporter and longtime Democratic Party fundraiser Barbra Streisand doesnāt think much of Donald Trump. The surprise is that the legendary singer chose to devote much of her new album, āWalls,ā to a series of laments about the U.S. presidentās policies.
Streisand never mentions the president by name, but she doesnāt have to. Opening track āWhatās on My Mindā speaks of her dashed hopes in the current era and asks, āHow did we come to this divide?ā The next one, āDonāt Lie to Me,ā is even more direct, beginning with, āWhy canāt you just tell me the truth? Hard to believe the things you say.ā
The title track complains about the divisive nature of building walls ā a familiar Trump campaign promise ā and even picks up Clintonās campaign theme that it is better to build bridges instead.
As a counterpoint to this gloom, she combines John Lennonās wistful āImagineā with the Louis Armstrong classic āWhat a Wonderful Worldā and also covers āWhat the World Needs Nowā in a paean to the redemptive power of love.
But those more hopeful tunes donāt really save this offering from its lugubrious tone. Streisandās vocal range and control are still extraordinary, but the lyrics often fall flat, as in āLady Liberty,ā which calls for the Statue of Liberty to āshow us how to stand and feel a little prouder.ā
Her magnificent voice, at times quivering with deeply felt emotion, may not be the perfect instrument for expressing pointed political anger, and the soft string accompaniment becomes a bit predictable.
The Trump era will surely produce a strong, outspoken musical response, perhaps from newer artists who have yet to be heard on the national stage, but Streisand here fails to break new ground. āWallsā will likely please her legions of fans ā she is one of the most popular recording artists of the last six decades ā but may not bring many new listeners to her side.
Comments