MUSIC REVIEW: Streisand's 'Walls' Strikes Strident Anti-Trump Tone

This cover image released by Columbia Records shows "Walls" a release by Barbra Streisand. (Columbia Records via AP)

BY GREGORY KATZ, AP

Barbra Streisand, ā€œWallsā€ (Columbia Records)

Itā€™s no surprise that fervent Hillary Clinton supporter and longtime Democratic Party fundraiser Barbra Streisand doesnā€™t think much of Donald Trump. The surprise is that the legendary singer chose to devote much of her new album, ā€œWalls,ā€ to a series of laments about the U.S. presidentā€™s policies.

Streisand never mentions the president by name, but she doesnā€™t have to. Opening track ā€œWhatā€™s on My Mindā€ speaks of her dashed hopes in the current era and asks, ā€œHow did we come to this divide?ā€ The next one, ā€œDonā€™t Lie to Me,ā€ is even more direct, beginning with, ā€œWhy canā€™t you just tell me the truth? Hard to believe the things you say.ā€

The title track complains about the divisive nature of building walls ā€” a familiar Trump campaign promise ā€” and even picks up Clintonā€™s campaign theme that it is better to build bridges instead.

As a counterpoint to this gloom, she combines John Lennonā€™s wistful ā€œImagineā€ with the Louis Armstrong classic ā€œWhat a Wonderful Worldā€ and also covers ā€œWhat the World Needs Nowā€ in a paean to the redemptive power of love.

But those more hopeful tunes donā€™t really save this offering from its lugubrious tone. Streisandā€™s vocal range and control are still extraordinary, but the lyrics often fall flat, as in ā€œLady Liberty,ā€ which calls for the Statue of Liberty to ā€œshow us how to stand and feel a little prouder.ā€

Her magnificent voice, at times quivering with deeply felt emotion, may not be the perfect instrument for expressing pointed political anger, and the soft string accompaniment becomes a bit predictable.

The Trump era will surely produce a strong, outspoken musical response, perhaps from newer artists who have yet to be heard on the national stage, but Streisand here fails to break new ground. ā€œWallsā€ will likely please her legions of fans ā€” she is one of the most popular recording artists of the last six decades ā€” but may not bring many new listeners to her side.

Comments

Popular Posts